Hi Bryce, I know how painful this feels.
The most effective first fix for recovered MP4s that will not play is to rebuild their missing header using an open source tool called untrunc. It repairs MP4s by borrowing a clean header from a short good clip recorded with the same app and settings. Here is exactly how to do it on Windows.
Open Medal and record a few seconds with the same game and the same recording settings you used for the lost clips. Keep this file safe. Name it good.mp4.
Now get untrunc for Windows from its official GitHub releases, then extract it to a simple folder such as C:\Tools\untrunc. Put good.mp4 and one of your broken files in that same folder. Always work on copies of the recovered files, not the originals.
Now open Windows Terminal or Command Prompt, cd to that folder, then run this command exactly:
untrunc.exe good.mp4 broken.mp4
If it works, you will see a new file alongside the original with a repaired header that should open in Movies and TV or VLC. If you have many files, you can repeat the command for each one. To speed that up you can use this simple loop:
for %f in ("C:\Recovered*.mp4") do C:\Tools\untrunc\untrunc.exe C:\Tools\untrunc\good.mp4 "%f"
That will attempt a repair on every MP4 in C:\Recovered using your good.mp4 as the template.
A few quick tips while you do this:
- Only try to repair files that are a realistic size for a clip. If a file is a few kilobytes, there is no video data left to salvage. If a file is hundreds of megabytes,
untrunchas a good chance.- Do not save anything new to the drive the clips were deleted from. Writing new data can overwrite pieces the recovery tool already found, which makes repairs impossible.
- Always verify by opening the repaired file in a player and scrubbing around. If audio works but video does not, or vice versa, try a second short reference clip from Medal using the exact same resolution and encoder option as before.
If untrunc reports that it cannot find usable video or audio streams, that usually means the recovery tool pulled back fragments only. In that case the next step would be a deeper pass with an open source carver and then a different repair path. Tell me what happens with untrunc and I will guide you to the next best move.