Windows 10, profile issues domain environment

PA2021C19 1 Reputation point


a little help with the following please.

We currently deploy windows 10 roaming profiles and folder redirection for version 1803, and are looking to move onto the latest version of Windows 10 and at the same time to come away from roaming profiles. We were thinking a mixture of UEV, folder redirection and local profiles which are removed on reboot as to not bloat the system but also for the fact no user stays on one PC they constantly roam.

Two issues with roaming profiles 1) always talked about them being old and possible something MS might remove at some point, 2) using roaming profiles on 1803 modern apps have never worked (this is the main issue i am to discuss)

On ANY version of windows 10 we have tested if user profiles (Cached) and removed at logoff/system startup the modern apps break on the second logon for a users with roaming/mandatory profiles.

IS there any method out there to support organizations of which their users are never at just one PC would like there settings to roam. But will always successfully launch modern apps?

It frustrating to think that a simple thing to want is being made impossible by Microsoft. Quick user logins, and all modern apps and settings to roam with users.

We are currently heading toward once again... either sticking with roaming profiles and folder redirection or having UEV with folder redirection but in both scenarios disabled the user of store apps and preinstalled store apps (which is what we do on 1803) we make the windows 7 calc available and enable in the registry photo viewer.
This options always feels like your defeated and going back a step but it is the only way we can give the users a nicer experience.

Having tried various solutions on the web which no-one ever fully resolves, reg changes, whether its permission changes on APPX properties clean up of profile sids, gpo settings to deploy apps in special profiles etc, none of this brings back the app successfully and or permeant.

Any advice would be much appreciated as so much time is being wasted just to get modern apps working.
What do people do on domains with multiple staff roaming? Do you disable modern apps yourselves? What profile and app settings methods do you use?

I have seen people mention fslogix but for us this is a none started due to it being an added cost

Many Thanks

Windows Group Policy
Windows Group Policy
A feature of Windows that enables policy-based administration using Active Directory.
1,883 questions
Windows 10
Windows 10
A Microsoft operating system that runs on personal computers and tablets.
6,004 questions
Windows 10 Setup
Windows 10 Setup
Windows 10: A Microsoft operating system that runs on personal computers and tablets.Setup: The procedures involved in preparing a software program or application to operate within a computer or mobile device.
1,731 questions
Windows 10 Compatibility
Windows 10 Compatibility
Windows 10: A Microsoft operating system that runs on personal computers and tablets.Compatibility: The extent to which hardware or software adheres to an accepted standard.
370 questions
Windows 10 Network
Windows 10 Network
Windows 10: A Microsoft operating system that runs on personal computers and tablets.Network: A group of devices that communicate either wirelessly or via a physical connection.
1,941 questions
No comments
{count} votes

2 answers

Sort by: Most helpful
  1. Leila Kong 3,666 Reputation points

    Hello @PA2021C19 ,

    Thanks for your query. Based on your description, we also recommend you to use fslogix, which is available for anyone with an RDS CAL or SAL at no extra cost since March 2019.

    You are eligible to access FSLogix Profile Container, Office 365 Container, Application Masking, and Java Redirection tools if you have one of the following licenses:

    Microsoft 365 E3/E5
    Microsoft 365 A3/A5/ Student Use Benefits
    Microsoft 365 F1/F3
    Microsoft 365 Business
    Windows 10 Enterprise E3/E5
    Windows 10 Education A3/A5
    Windows 10 VDA per user
    Remote Desktop Services (RDS) Client Access License (CAL)
    Remote Desktop Services (RDS) Subscriber Access License (SAL)

    What is FSLogix?:

    Best regards,


    If the Answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and upvote it.
    Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.

    No comments

  2. PA2021C19 1 Reputation point

    Hello thank you for your response but i did say FSlogix is not available to us as it is an added cost.

    I know the options which allow it for free and we do not own them so FSlogix is not possible