Good Day LyndseyMcMillan,
My name is Carlo, I am also using Windows 11 pc and community member like you. Let us work together to sort this out.
Here's the steps you can try.
-Click Start, type Powershell and open it.
-Copy and paste this command below and hit Enter.
Get-AppxPackage *windows.immersivecontrolpanel* | Reset-AppxPackage
Restart your computer and check.
I hope the information above helps. Please let me know how it goes.
Have a wonderful day ahead and stay safe.
Sincerely,
Carlo T.