Hi Thomas McCabe,
Welcome to Microsoft Q&A.
Outlook (classic) does support POP3. If a Yahoo POP setup “fails to connect,” it’s usually due to Yahoo authentication/security requirements (often needing an App Password) or incorrect POP/SMTP ports/encryption—not because POP is unsupported.
Step 1: Add the Yahoo account as POP3 (keep IMAP temporarily for comparison)
In Outlook (classic):
- Go to File > Add Account
- Enter your Yahoo address
- Select Advanced options > Let me set up my account manually > POP
Use Yahoo’s official POP settings:
- Incoming (POP):
pop.mail.yahoo.com— Port 995 — SSL - Outgoing (SMTP):
smtp.mail.yahoo.com— Port 465 (SSL) or 587 (TLS) - Username: full email address
Note: If Outlook rejects your normal Yahoo password, generate and use a Yahoo App Password.
When you enter the App Password in Outlook, make sure to check “Remember password” so Outlook keeps the credential after restarting (Yahoo app passwords are one-time shown, so it’s best not to rely on re-entering it later).
Step 2: Make POP behave the way most people expect (don’t accidentally “pull mail off the server”)
POP can download mail locally and may remove it from the server depending on settings. If you also use Yahoo webmail or a phone/tablet:
- Go to Account Settings > Change > More Settings > Advanced
- Check Leave a copy of messages on the server (recommended for multi-device access)
(You’ll still have local storage in Outlook via the PST, but this prevents surprises across devices.)
Step 3: Verify the POP mailbox is working before removing IMAP
Now you can compare them side-by-side:
- Confirm POP is sending/receiving
- Confirm mail is being stored locally as expected (POP will generally download to a local data file)
If everything looks good, then remove the old IMAP account:
- File > Account Settings > Account Settings
- Select the Yahoo IMAP account > Remove
(Optional safety step) If you have mail in the IMAP mailbox you want to keep as a local backup, export it first: File > Open & Export > Import/Export > Export to .pst
If it still won’t connect
If POP still fails even with the correct server settings and an App Password, please share the exact Outlook error message (especially the last line). That will help identify whether it’s authentication, ports/encryption, or stored credentials.
Please let me know if this proves useful to you, or if you would like further assistance.
I'm looking forward to your reply.
If the answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and kindly upvote it. If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment”.
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.