A family of Microsoft spreadsheet software with tools for analyzing, charting, and communicating data
Dear @Mark Stevens,
Thank you for reaching out with this detailed question. It’s a very specific issue, but I’ve seen similar cases where files behave differently between versions of Excel. Let’s break down what is likely happening and how you can resolve it.
Based on the error message you received, the core issue is that Excel 2024 LTS is flagging specific elements within the file (like properties in the workbook and worksheets) as "unreadable content" and is removing them during the recovery process, while Excel 365 ignores these same elements and opens the file without issue.
This usually points to a difference in how the two versions handle file validation and legacy features. Excel 365 is constantly updated and might be more forgiving or have newer libraries to interpret the file's structure. Excel 2024 LTS, being a "Long Term Servicing" channel release, is a static snapshot of features and might have stricter or different rules for validating the XML structure inside the .xlsx file. The items being removed (properties) are often metadata, custom document properties, or data validation settings that Excel 2024 no longer recognizes or supports in the same way.
To fix this, I recommend a direct, two-pronged approach:
- Clean and Resave the File in Excel 365: This is the most reliable solution. Since the file opens perfectly in Excel 365, we can use it to "clean" the problematic parts.
- Open the affected file in your Excel 365.
- Go to File > Info and click on Check for Issues (next to the Inspect Workbook button).
- Select Inspect Document. This tool scans for hidden metadata and other content.
- In the dialog that appears, ensure all checkboxes are selected (especially "Document Properties and Personal Information") and click Inspect.
- If the inspector finds document properties, click Remove All next to that category.
- After the cleanup, save the file with a new name (e.g.,
yourfile_fixed.xlsx). - Now, try opening this newly cleaned file in your Excel 2024 LTS. This process often strips out the exact "features" that were causing the conflict.
- Check for a Microsoft Update (as a Workaround): I've seen reports of specific Excel 2024 builds (like Version 2408 Build 17932.20620) introducing unexpected behavior with certain file elements. While those reports focus on VBA and database connections, the underlying principle is the same: a build-specific change can cause file compatibility issues.
- First, ensure your Excel 2024 LTS is fully updated. Go to File > Account > Update Options > Update Now. Microsoft may have released a patch that addresses this file validation problem.
- Second, if the problem persists and you urgently need to work, you could consider rolling back to a previous, stable version of Office 2024 LTS, as this has helped others in similar situations. However, this is a more technical workaround and should only be done if you are comfortable with IT administration tasks, as it involves uninstalling the current version and installing an older build.
You can refer to a similar situation in another article within the community: Excel problem after updated Office 2024. - Microsoft Q&A
Please try the first solution and let me know if it resolves the issue. If not, we can dig deeper into the possibility of a build-specific bug.
If the answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and kindly upvote it. If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment".
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.