Hi Bram White, SIOR,
I understand how this can be confusing, especially when you’ve already created the PST file and it looks like it should open normally. Based on my research, this behavior is actually expected in Outlook and does not indicate an issue with your PST file.
Outlook data files (.pst) cannot be opened by double‑clicking them from File Explorer. They must be added (attached) from within Outlook itself. The message “Outlook data files must be opened from within Outlook” is simply informing you of the correct method.
Please follow these steps directly from Outlook:
1. Open Outlook (Classic for Windows).
2. Click File > Open & Export > Open Outlook Data File.
3. Browse to Documents\Outlook Files.
4. Select your newly created .pst file and click OK.
5. Once added, the PST file will appear in the left folder pane (usually at the bottom of the mailbox list).
After the PST is attached:
- Locate the folder you want to copy (for example, a custom folder under Inbox).
- Right‑click the folder and select Copy Folder….
- In the Copy Folder window:
- Select the new PST file (or a folder inside it) as the destination > Click OK.
Outlook will create a complete copy of the selected folder, including all emails and subfolders, inside the PST file.
Note:
- Copy Folder keeps the original folder intact.
- Avoid using Move Folder unless you intend to remove the folder from its original location.
You may find the following official Microsoft articles useful for additional context: Open and close Outlook Data Files (.pst)
I hope this explanation helps clarify why you’re seeing that message and guides you in the right direction. If anything above is unclear, or if you have additional questions, please feel free to let me know.
If the answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and kindly upvote it. If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment".
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.