Hi Jeffrey Harris,
Thank you for reaching out.
When the new Windows 11 PC has already completed setup, the built‑in PC‑to‑PC transfer feature may no longer allow the two computers to pair. This transfer experience is designed to work during the initial setup phase of the new device.
Here are some available options that you can consider trying in this situation:
Option 1: Reset the new PC (only if you want PC‑to‑PC transfer)
- Open Settings > System > Recovery
- Select Reset this PC
- Choose Keep my files
- During setup, sign in with the same personal Microsoft account used on the Windows 10 PC
- Follow the on‑screen prompts to transfer files during setup
Option 2: Move files without resetting (recommended for files only)
- Sign in to OneDrive on the Windows 10 PC and allow files to sync
- Sign in to OneDrive on the Windows 11 PC using the same account
- Access files directly from File Explorer
Option 3: Use an external drive
- Copy files from the Windows 10 PC to a USB or external drive
- Connect the drive to the Windows 11 PC and copy the files over
Resetting the new PC is only needed if you specifically want to use the automatic PC‑to‑PC transfer during setup. If your goal is simply to move files, using OneDrive or an external drive is usually faster and avoids resetting the device.
Let me know if you need further assistance, feel free to ask me by clicking "Add Comment" or "Add Answer" if you cannot add comment so your response will be visible. Thanks for your effort.
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.