Hi Al G,
The message “Outlook does not yet support adding Shared mailboxes this way. Try adding another account” usually indicates that New Outlook is interpreting the address as a shared/delegated mailbox or an alias, rather than as a normal primary account.
Because the same mailbox works on your other laptop and on your phone, the mailbox itself is likely OK. In cases like this, especially after a PC refresh or rebuild. New Outlook can sometimes misidentify the account due to local app data or because the address being entered is not the primary Microsoft account alias.
You can try the following steps in order:
- Test the mailbox in Outlook on the web
Sign in at https://outlook.live.com using the same address. If it opens there, that points to an issue with New Outlook on this PC rather than with the mailbox itself.
- Check whether the address is the Microsoft account’s primary alias
If the email address is only a secondary alias, try signing in using the primary alias for the Microsoft account instead.
- Reset New Outlook to clear its local app data (including the Olk cache)
Go to Settings > Apps > Installed apps > Outlook (new) > Advanced options > Reset, then reopen Outlook and add the account again.
Note: This clears New Outlook’s local settings and cache on this device only.
- If it still fails, switch back to Classic Outlook and try adding the account there
Microsoft still allows switching back to Classic Outlook, and in some cases Classic Outlook can add the mailbox successfully even when New Outlook misidentifies it.
- If the mailbox is actually shared or delegated
Add it using Add shared folder or mailbox / Shared with me instead of Add account, as New Outlook does not support adding shared mailboxes as full accounts.
If you reply with:
- whether it works in Outlook on the web
- whether the address is the primary alias
- whether resetting New Outlook made any difference
When I have that information, I can suggest the most appropriate next step based on that.
Please let me know if this proves useful to you, or if you would like further assistance.
I'm looking forward to your reply.
If the answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and kindly upvote it. If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment”.
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.