Hi Laura Wagner,
The behavior you’re seeing usually happens because the old mapping was created with a different action type (like “Update” or “Create”), and the new “Replace” setting doesn’t fully clean up the legacy link. As a result, Windows ends up showing both the dead mapping and the new one.
To fix this, I recommend explicitly setting the preference item to “Delete” the old drive mapping first, then adding the new DFS path as a separate “Create” or “Replace” action. You can also enable the “Remove when not applied” option in the GPO preference item, which ensures that any drive mappings not valid anymore are cleaned up automatically. After making these changes, run gpupdate /force on a test machine to confirm the old mapping disappears.
Another tip is to check the item-level targeting conditions, sometimes a mismatch there can cause both mappings to appear. Cleaning up the legacy entry and re‑deploying the new one usually resolves the issue across all endpoints.
I hope the response provided some helpful insight. If you find this answer useful, please hit “accept answer” so I know it addressed your concern.
Jason.