From your description, it sounds like Windows may be using cached monitor information or is not correctly detecting the unique display identifiers (EDID) for each monitor. This can sometimes happen after display hardware changes, driver updates, or when using adapters, docks, or other intermediary devices.
Here are some additional steps that may help:
- Open Device Manager > View > Show hidden devices.
- Expand Monitors and uninstall all monitor entries, including any greyed-out devices.
- Restart the PC and allow Windows to detect the displays again.
If you're using a dock, KVM switch, hub, or video adapter, temporarily connect the monitors directly to the computer (if possible) and check whether they are identified correctly. Please verify whether both displays appear separately under Settings > System > Display and Device Manager > Monitors after reconnection.
If the issue continues, please share how the monitors are connected (directly, via dock, adapter, KVM, etc.) and what appears under Device Manager > Monitors. That information can help narrow down whether the behavior is related to display detection, graphics drivers, or the connection hardware.
Let me know if you need further assistance, feel free to ask me by clicking "Add Comment" or "Add Answer" if you cannot add comment so your response will be visible. Thanks for your effort.
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.