I understand how confusing this can be when your newly purchased Surface Slim Pen cannot be registered, especially when the keyboard registers successfully. However, this behavior is usually expected, as Surface Slim Pen or other Surface accessories (except Surface keyboards/Type Covers) could not be registered as a standalone.
Just wondering, did you purchase the Surface Pro Keyboard and Slim Pen as a bundle, or were they purchased separately? If it's the former and the keyboard is already registered, just save your proof of purchase or invoice for the bundle for future. When you ever need service for the Slim Pen, use the registered Surface device/accessory service process.
If it's the latter case, you would need to contact Microsoft Support directly (for example: When requesting a repair for the surface type cover and pen, there is no option to choose it, inste…). Provide them the proof of purchase for your Slim Pen and they will help you figure out what's the best option next:
- Visit Contact Us - Microsoft Support > Sign in
- Type in your problem > click Get Help to make request
- Scroll to the bottom and click Contact Support to connect to agent
- Select category again > continue and you should be added to a chat queue.
- If you don't see the chat option, go through another category and request escalate.
Note: The support contact team only works at certain times, so if the last window shows that it's unavailable, try opening it again the next day. If you prefer phone support, you can leave a phone number. This way, they can call you and help you.
Hopefully this helps clarify the situation. If you would like additional reassurance that the pen is covered, you can also contact Support right now for more suggestions.
If you think the answer is helpful to you, please mark this as accepted. If you have extra questions about this answer, feel free to click "Add Comment" and ask!
Note: Follow the steps in our documentation if you want to enable and receive the related email notifications for this thread.