The annoying this is, is that is DOES work until you change the duplication. Typically a teacher will have their lesson on the desktop monitor and projector, so students can see it, and their email on the laptop screen, so it is private.
A reg setting must be created and if I would find what that is, a simple deltion should return it to the default of being able to extend across all three diaplays. You shouldn't have to reinstall the machine to reset it to factory default.