Hello Robert Coeshall,
Thanks for reaching out. For me to understand the situation completely and help you best, could you share a bit more details?
- Which Outlook are you using — the New Outlook for Windows, Classic Outlook (the older desktop app), or Outlook.com in a browser? (The tick/checkbox showing up on a single click suggests New Outlook or the web version.)
- Does Shift work normally in other apps — for example, can you Shift+click to select a range of files in File Explorer, or hold Shift to type capital letters?
- Anything recent that might be relevant — Windows update, Outlook update, a new keyboard, or any accessibility settings turned on lately?
It's possible that Sticky Keys or Filter Keys under Windows accessibility settings can sometimes break the Shift modifier across apps, and a stuck/failing Shift key would look the same. If Shift+click works fine in File Explorer, then we know it's specifically an Outlook-side issue and we can dig from there.