Hi @Gregg Pfeifer,
First please check the error log to see if there are any information for us to narrow down the issue.
You may also check below links to see if you have missed any steps when you configure the certificate.
Configure SSRS with an SSL Certificate
Configure TLS connections on a native mode report server
Regards,
Zoe Hui
If the answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and upvote it.