Hi Tjibbe Kooistra,
I know this is a stressful situation to run into, especially when you never knowingly enabled BitLocker. To not waste you more time on this, I’ll go straight to the point:
- The data on the
D:drive cannot be recovered without the BitLocker recovery key. - The drive itself is not physically damaged and can be reused after wiping and reformatting.
If your goal is data recovery, this is unfortunately not possible. Unless the recovery key was saved to a Microsoft account, printed, stored on a USB file, or linked to a work/school account, there is no way to unlock the drive. No Windows command, reinstall, or Microsoft Support option can bypass BitLocker encryption.
If your goal is to restore your PC to full functionality, you can delete the encrypted D: partition, create a new simple volume and reformat the drive. If you can still log into Windows, you can do it from Disk Management. This will unfortunately erase all data on it, but the drive will then work normally as empty storage.
BitLocker may have automatically encrypted the D: drive in the past, and that encryption was tied to the original system environment. When the C: drive was replaced and Windows reinstalled, that trust chain was broken. The message about the encryption being “not compatible with this Windows version” simply means the original environment no longer exists.
If you need more guidance on deleting the encrypted drive and creating the new volume, let me know and we will work on that together.
If the answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and kindly upvote it. If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment".
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.