Hello, billiardsnut
Are you using an adapter for DVI or HDMI?
Assuming you are using a straight DVI->DVI or HDMI->HDMI cable, try shutting down the computer and turning off the monitor, connect the DV or HDMI cable, then turn both back on.
Some video cards will not dynamically change on its own, doing the above steps will usually set the appropriate output.
Additionally, since you mention on your old monitor it would be intermittent, it could possibly be the digital (DVI/HDMI) port on your video card is failing.
David
Microsoft Answers Support Engineer
Visit our Microsoft Answers Feedback Forum and let us know what you think.