I am having the same problem. The posted fix above indicates the option to extend "is only available when there is contiguous unallocated space behind the volume which you want to extend." I show 746.52GB of unallocated space immediately following the primary partition... but the option to extend is still grey. Please advise.
I have data on my primary partition now so was hoping to extend without any reformatting. Thanks.
I'm now running Windows 10 if that matters.