I have exactly the same problem as above. I am unable to turn on Windows Defender. When I try method 1 to start it manually I get
Windows could not start the Windows Defender Service on local computer.
Error 577: Windows cannot verify the digital signature for this file. A recent hardware or software change might have installed a file that is signed incorrectly or damaged, or that might be malicious software from an unknown source.
I was unable to start Windows Defender when I bought this laptop new a couple of months ago. It simply would not turn on. Then I updated from Windows 8 to 8.1
The Lavasoft antivrius I had installed (when I found Defender would not work) to protect the laptop would not work any more with the update to 8.1
So I uninstalled and reinstalled Lavasoft but it still would not work so I uninstalled it again. My laptop is now currently unprotected apart from the free version of Spybot Search and Destroy 2.2 which is the only thing I can find that seems to work with Windows 8.1
There appears to be almost nothing that works in the free antivirus protection now, your Microsoft list says most stuff is incompatible or unknown.
I would very much appreciate some help here to get Windows Defender to work, or please could you point me in the direction of some free antivirus software that will work. Or give me some plan whereby I can protect my computer.