Hi Dylan,
I would suggest you to try these steps to calibrate your pen and touch settings.
a. Open the charms using the keyboard shortcut Windows logo key +C, and then tap or click Search.
b. Enter Calibrate in the search box, and then tap or click Calibrate the screen for pen or touch input to open Tablet PC Settings.
c. Check that the monitor shown in the Display field matches the screen you want to calibrate.
d. Tap or click Reset, you might be asked for an admin password or to confirm your choice.
Refer to the article for additional information.
****Hope this information helps. Reply to the post with updated status of the issue to assist you further.