Hi Andre - Thank you for your reply! I've actually gone through that whole article before posting, and mentioned in my original post that I've entered in all of those settings. The only difference is that I'm not using the tool "WakeonLAN" utility to wake my desktop because I'm either waking it from a chromebook or over the internet on my phone using Depicus's online wake on lan site: (https://www.depicus.com/wake-on-lan/)
The article you sent suggests that I'm waking a computer using another windows machine where I have that "WakeonLAN" utility installed. The site that I'm using allows me to put in my IP, Port, etc. so that I don't need to have a specific tool and can wake from anywhere using the site alone.
Any other suggestions on options that I need to check? Either on my Windows device configurations or maybe my router?