Hello Todd,
Thank you for contacting Microsoft community. I'd like to let you know this is a peer-to-peer support forum meaning I'm just fellow regular MS forum users like you who are trying to help other MS forum users with their issues. I'm a Non-Microsoft Staff I don't have access to your account, nor I'm authorized to do so.
Go to Teams Web App, select “Use the web app instead,” and check if you encounter the same error. This will help us isolate the issue between the desktop app and the web app
Use Teams Troubleshooter:
Try using the Teams Troubleshooter. Open your browser and go to office.com.
Search for “Diag: Missing Recording” in the help dialog box.
Enter the URL and date of the meeting, and you’ll receive a URL to type into your browser.
The meeting recording should download.
Clear App Cache: If the issue persists on the Teams desktop app, clear the app cache.
You can follow the steps here to clear the cache.https://www.uvm.edu/it/kb/article/clearing-team
confirm if you are able to download
If the issue persist I suggest that you reach out to your admin (if you're not) and open up an official support ticket with from the admin portal.
Ruth
Regards