You can probably get there with a bit of VBA. This seems to work, though it might need a few adjustments (color, size and so on). It won't be quite as simple to undo it once it's done, so test it, make sure it works, then don't use it on your REAL slides
until you're sure you won't be changing them again; renumbering would require you to remove what's been added manually.
The text boxes have to be formatted a certain way to begin with; you should be able to do this on your slide master. See the notes in Sub TestMe. It's important to select ALL the text in the text box before setting the indents/tab. This shows what the
ruler should look like:
First line indent all the way to the left,
Second line indent and first tab indented however much you like but at the same position

Option Explicit
Sub TestMe()
' Select the text box that needs special bullets
' then run this TestMe subroutine (press F5)
' The text should have bullets set to NONE
' There should be a second line indent and a left tab set to the same
' place on the ruler, else it won't work
Dim oSh As Shape
Set oSh = ActiveWindow.Selection.ShapeRange(1)
Call BulletizeMe(oSh)
End Sub
Sub BulletizeMe(oSh As Shape)
Dim x As Long
With oSh
For x = 1 To .TextFrame.TextRange.Paragraphs.Count
With .TextFrame2
With .TextRange.Paragraphs(x)
.Characters.Text = "LO" & CStr(x) & vbTab & Left$(.Text, Len(.Text) - 1)
With .Characters(1, 3).Font
.Name = "Rockwell"
.Fill.ForeColor.RGB = RGB(0, 127, 0)
End With
With .Characters(1, 2).Font
.Smallcaps = True
' and because setting Smallcaps on Rockwell seems to
' have no effect, you might also want to uncomment
' the following, which shrinks it to 80% of it's former self
.Size = .Size * 0.8
End With
End With ' textrange
End With ' textframe
Next ' paragraph
End With ' Shape
End Sub