Hi Sebastian Bienert ,
To add to the previous comment, if I am understanding your requirement, the behavior you are describing would be an intentional limitation of the product.
When users sign-up using userID, the email address they verified during sign-up was just added to their Auth Methods--Email like below. And one problem is that we do allow multiple users to use the same email address from the Auth method when resetting passwords. There would be an issue if you are only using email for password reset for userID sign-up users, since the email address verified in auth method might map to multiple userIDs.
Let me know if this helps answer your question. If you would like to leave a request for this feature and provide a business justification, you can do so in the feedback forum. https://feedback.azure.com/
-
If the information accurately addressed your question, please Accept the answer. This will help us as well as others in the community who might be researching similar questions.