Why isn't Action.Execute including Input Values when operating within a channel?

Question

I have the following Adaptive Card:

{
  contentType: "application/vnd.microsoft.card.adaptive",
  content: {
    type: "AdaptiveCard",
    version: "1.5",
    body: [
      {
        type: "Input.Text",
        id: "someText",
        value: "1",
        maxLength: 100,
      }
    ],
    actions: [
      {
        type: "Action.Submit",
        title: "Submit",
        id: "submit",
        verb: "submit",
        data: {"action": "submit"},
      },
      {
        type: "Action.Execute",
        title: "Execute",
        id: "execute",
        verb: "execute",
        data: {"action": "execute"}
      }
    ],
}       

If I click either button in personal chat with a bot, the bot receives a value for someText as I'd expect.

In a Team Channel, I receive someText with the Action.Submit action, but not with the Action.Execute button. Action.Execute was working a few weeks ago.

How do I use the Action.Execute action type and also receive Input values from the Card?

Answer 1

After 2 months of it not working, this is now working for me.

Answer 2

We are also able to repro the issue. In a Team Channel, we received someText with the Action.Submit action, but not with the Action.Execute button.

//extract from request payload with Submit action

"value": {
        "action": "submit",
        "someText": "Submit value"
    },

//extract from request payload with Execute action

"value": {
        "action": {
            "type": "Action.Execute",
            "id": "execute",
            "title": "Execute",
            "data": {
                "action": "execute"
            },
            "verb": "execute"
        },
        "trigger": "manual"
    },

We have raised a bug for the same. We will inform you once we get any further update from engineering team. Thanks!

Thanks, 

Prasad Das

************************************************************************* 

If the response is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and upvote it. You can share your feedback via Microsoft Teams Developer Feedback link

Answer 3

We are experiencing the exact same thing. Started yesterday with an app that's been running great for a year. Same issue - the Execute action does not post the input fields back to the server.

What we did discover however, is that it works if we run Teams via Google Chrome - but not Firefox, Edge or the desktop app.

Seems like Microsoft changes something here?

Has anybody seen any official posts on this?

Answer 4

Thought I was going crazy here, app was working one day and broken the next. Experiencing the same issue, data from associated inputs when action.execute is called from a card in a Teams Channel does not flow through. This only works in a personal chat.

Answer 5

MS Team, can sb take a look on this issue? It's blocking our development. Do you have any automation tests for this area? How is it possible that some feature works fine and suddenly is broken completely? Any ETA for fix?