Differences between GC.Collect method and JavaScript's window.gc method

Question

Version .NET Framework 4.8

What are the differences between the GC.Collect method and JavaScript's window.gc method? Specifically, what are the differences in the scope of objects targeted for garbage collection?

Is there a possibility that manually executing garbage collection could lead to instability in the operation of the OS or applications?

Answer 1

Hi @Kazuki Yagi , Welcome to Microsoft Q&A,

GC.Collect Method in .NET Framework 4.8:

The GC.Collect method in the .NET Framework 4.8 is used to trigger garbage collection explicitly. Garbage collection is an automatic process in .NET where the runtime manages memory by reclaiming memory occupied by objects that are no longer reachable. Calling GC.Collect can be used to suggest to the garbage collector that it should perform a collection cycle, but it doesn't guarantee an immediate collection.

JavaScript's window.gc Method:

The window.gc method in JavaScript is a non-standard method that suggests to the JavaScript engine's garbage collector to perform a collection cycle. However, its behavior is not standardized and its effectiveness varies across different browsers and environments. In modern JavaScript, memory management is automatic with the use of a garbage collector, and developers don't typically need to manually trigger garbage collection.

Differences in Scope of Objects Targeted for Garbage Collection:

In both cases, the primary goal of garbage collection is to identify and clean up memory that is no longer accessible or used by the program. However, the specifics of how objects are identified and collected differ between the .NET Framework and JavaScript:

• .NET Framework: The garbage collector in .NET targets objects that are no longer reachable through references from the application's roots (such as static variables, method parameters, and local variables). It employs various techniques like generational garbage collection to efficiently manage memory.
• JavaScript: JavaScript uses a garbage collector that generally employs a technique called "reachability analysis." Objects that are no longer reachable from the root of the object graph (usually the global object or objects referenced from the executing code) become eligible for garbage collection.

Manually Executing Garbage Collection and Instability:

In both .NET and JavaScript, manually triggering garbage collection is generally not recommended unless you have a very specific reason to do so, and you have a deep understanding of the memory management mechanisms of the platform. Manually invoking garbage collection should not typically lead to instability in the operation of the operating system or applications. However, there are some considerations to keep in mind:

1. Performance Impact: Manually invoking garbage collection can impact performance, as it might trigger unnecessary collection cycles, causing application slowdowns.
2. Unpredictable Behavior: Depending on the memory management algorithms employed by the platform, manually invoking garbage collection might not result in the expected memory reclamation.
3. Platform Variability: The behavior of garbage collection, especially in JavaScript, can vary across browsers and environments. Manually triggering garbage collection might have different effects in different contexts.
4. Automatic Management: Modern memory management systems are designed to handle memory efficiently on their own. Manually interfering with garbage collection might disrupt this automatic management.

In conclusion, while both the .NET Framework's GC.Collect method and JavaScript's window.gc method provide ways to trigger garbage collection, they should be used sparingly and with a solid understanding of the underlying memory management systems to avoid potential performance issues and unexpected behavior.

You can also check the official documentation about GC.

Best Regards,

Jiale

---

If the answer is the right solution, please click "Accept Answer" and kindly upvote it. If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment". 

Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.