Hello Z AJ Jones ,
Thank you for raising your question in the Microsoft Q&A Community.
To start with, audit logs are available for 90 days only in Azure DevOps Services as you have mentioned. However, since you said the screenshots are a but different, be sure that you have enabled auditing within your ADO and do not confuse this with the Usage tab.
In case you haven't enabled this, click on Policies in your Organization settings then enable the auditing
If you have this enabled, then check the filter in the above screenshot and set the date accordingly.
Let me know if further assistance is required.
Babafemi