Hi,
The method that you have tried is actually the way to keep new programs from getting highlighted.
This will remain un-highlighted only when this option is unchecked. If you check it back, the program will again get highlighted in the start menu.
So it’s by design that the program has to be opened atleast once to remove the highlight from the list.
Regards,
Syed N – Microsoft Support
Visit our Microsoft Answers Feedback Forum and let us know what you think.