Hello KJ Fuhrmann.
Thanks for your reply.
It seems that you have tried reinstalling the system, but you are still encountering a PIN code issue.
Did you preserve the personal data when reinstalling? Generally, the PIN code is stored locally in a folder called "NGC."
If you perform a clean installation without preserving the data, you should not encounter this problem.
In general, the changes you make to your settings should not affect the existence of the PIN code. However, you can give it a try.
Some users have reported that after restarting the secure boot option, they were able to use the PIN code to log in to the system
without encountering the previous issue where the correct PIN was being recognized as incorrect.
If you wish to communicate directly with support personnel, you can visit the website mentioned and follow the steps provided to access online support.
Access this website and then enter your issue in the text box->Click get help->Click Contact support->Select Windows Account security->
Click Confirm.
Best Regards,
Tommy-MSFT | Microsoft Community Support Specialist