Hi HailyBuckman, hope you're doing well. I’m Ian, and I’m happy to help you today.
In this case you need intermediary list which consist the unique data you have.
- Click the Data Ribbon Menu
- Select the Advanced Button in the Sort & Filter section
- Fill in the dialog Box, copying the results to another location and making sure you tick Unique records only
- After creating a unique list, you can now implement the COUNTIF to count the number of occurrences
Please see sample below.
This is a user-to-user support forum and I am a fellow user.
I hope this helps, but please let me know if you need anything else.