I don't know if we can change the behavior of the "," style button on the left. (See the image below.)
But we can click the Comma [0] style on the right.
In Excel 2010, I click the scroll-down or end arrow to the right of the Styles area.
I don't know if we can reorder the Styles so that Comma [0] is more accessible. In fact, an old answers.microsoft.com thread claims that we cannot.
But we can right-click Comma [0] and click Duplicate, which creates Comma [0] 2 and puts it at the top. We can also rename the duplicate Style.
All of that might be done differently in MS365 Excel (sigh).