Dear respected Brian Galloway1,
Good day! Thank you for posting to Microsoft Community. We are happy to help you.
As per your description, here is sample formula:
Assumptions:
Sheet1 has the location numbers in Column A, and you want to return the manager's name in Column B.
Sheet2 has the location numbers in Column A, user titles in Column B, and manager names in Column C.
In Sheet1, go to cell B2 (or wherever you want to place the manager's name) and enter this formula:
=VLOOKUP(A2, Sheet2!A:C, 3, FALSE)
If there is any misunderstanding, I apologize and if it is convenient for you, could you please send copy of your document file to me so that I can look from my side, and I will check this behavior and help you to fix and verify the result with you.
If there is confidential information, then you can send it to me in Private Message(PM). you can access PM from the top right corner of this page, as shown in image below:

Please understand that our initial reply may not always immediately resolve the issue. However, with your help and more detailed information, we can work together to find a solution.
I'm sorry and I apologize for that.
Appreciate your patience and understanding and thank you for your time and cooperation.
Sincerely,
Waqas Muhammad