Hi Cooper Turner,
The Antimalware Service Executable process causing sustained high CPU usage is typically caused by Windows Defender scanning its own installation directory or hitting a continuous loop while monitoring active game files. Since you notice this loop specifically dragging down your gaming performance, the most permanent solution is to add a process and folder exclusion to the security agent. Open Windows Security => click on Virus & threat protection =>go to Manage settings under the protection settings header=>select Add or remove exclusions and add the folder path C:\Program Files\Windows Defender, along with the specific main folder where your games are installed.
This background resource hogging can occur if Windows Task Scheduler is triggered to run a daily scan with unrestricted CPU access. You can tone this down by opening Task Scheduler, navigating to the Microsoft\Windows\Windows Defender folder, opening the Windows Defender Scheduled Scan properties & under the Conditions tab, making sure it is set to run only when the computer is completely idle.
If adding these target exclusions stabilizes your CPU usage and stops the in game lagging, please click "Accept Answer" so other community members running into this high resource consumption can find this workaround.
Tracy.