Dear @Moulissa Poole
Since you still have access to the old device, you can use it to approve the authentication request while registering Microsoft Authenticator on the new device.
For a Work or School account, the correct starting point is:
https://aka.ms/MySecurityInfo
From there:
- Sign in with your Work or School account.
- Select Add sign-in method.
- Select Microsoft Authenticator.
- Continue through the setup until the QR code is displayed.
- Open the Microsoft Authenticator app on your phone.
- Select + --› Work or school account.
- Select Scan a QR code and scan the code displayed in the browser.
- Complete the verification test.
The important distinction is that Microsoft Authenticator is not where the authentication method itself is configured. The registration is initiated through the Microsoft Entra Security info page, while the Authenticator app is used to complete the registration and approve authentication requests.
For a Personal Microsoft account, the process is different. Go to:
https://account.microsoft.com/security
Then select Manage how I sign in and add Microsoft Authenticator as a verification method.
If you're looking for settings such as authentication methods, registration requirements, or policies, these are not configured in the Authenticator app. For Work or School accounts, those controls are managed through Microsoft Entra ID and can also be restricted by the organization's configuration.
In short:
Work/School account → https://aka.ms/MySecurityInfo
Personal Microsoft account → https://account.microsoft.com/security
The Authenticator app handles the authentication experience; the account and authentication configuration is managed through the relevant Microsoft portal.
If this answers your query, please click Accept Answer and Upvote if you found it helpful. If you have any further questions, feel free to let us know.