Hello BrandonCastor,
Thank you for your question and reaching out.
I can understand you are facing with smart card login after migration of your CA.
It can be issue with KDC certificate which may be not updated after migration of CA. I will suggest you to check Event logs in your DC and on your CA server while login using smart card.
Let me share you some good troubleshooting thread URLs which should be helpful to resolve this issue.
--If the reply is helpful, please Upvote and Accept as answer--