Office Add-in UI/UX - New menu item or add to existing menu?

PETTERSEN Stein Olav 1 Reputation point

Made some UX-research regarding Add-ins. Found that some providers add their own Add-in to the main menu to get their own ribbon. There are some pros and cons:

Easy access: By adding the Add-in to the main menu the providers add-in become easy to find in the ribbon as the ribbon will only contain the providers add-in.

Two clicks: Accessing the add-in will need two clicks: First from the main menu, then from the icon in the ribbon to activate the add-in in the task pane.
Zig-zag eye navigation: New main menu item will be added to the right of all default items. Providers add-in Icon will be added to the far left in the ribbon. The task pane will open to the far right side in the app-window. The tooltip is pointing at the add-in at the main menu - not on the add-in icon in the ribbon.
Overload: If all providers do it this way the main menu will be overloaded with add-ins

One of the main reasons for adding the providers add-in to the main menu is accessibility issues. In cases where the ribbon is minimised (by default at typically a stuffed Home-ribbon) the add-in icon is not visible for the users. Maximising the ribbon is done by clicking a tiny and almost hidden chevron. When maximised the add-in is visible

Wonder if it is possible to automatic - or in some way - always maximise the ribbon when adding new add-ins?
Do Microsoft have any usability tests telling which solution is preferred? Either adding the add-in to the main menu - or adding it to one of the existing menus (Home, Insert, etc). It would help a lot in my case.

(Another alternative solution might be an Add-in item added to the main menu where all providers could put their add-ins to access them from one common ribbon)

Office Development
Office Development
Office: A suite of Microsoft productivity software that supports common business tasks, including word processing, email, presentations, and data management and analysis.Development: The process of researching, productizing, and refining new or existing technologies.
3,461 questions
0 comments No comments
{count} votes