Hello @Rockwell, D
The DHCP leases work with MAC addresses, and it will not be possible to assign 2 different IPs to the same NIC(MAC) however, you may check if you have other connections, such as VPN, Wireless, other Miniports, etc... as this may be cause of the IP duplication.
I would help if you could share an output of IPCONFIG /ALL from one of the affected machines
Also, dont forget to check in the DHCP server Event Viewers for errors/warnings related to DHCP as this can give a wider understanding if there is an issue.
Hope this helps with your query,
------
--If the reply is helpful, please Upvote and Accept as answer--