CA2224：多載等號比較運算子時必須一併覆寫 Equals
型別名稱 |
OverrideEqualsOnOverloadingOperatorEquals |
CheckId |
CA2224 |
分類 |
Microsoft.Usage |
中斷變更 |
不中斷 |
原因
public 型別會實作等號比較運算子，但不會覆寫 Object.Equals。
規則描述
等號比較運算子主要是在語法上提供便利的使用方式，以存取 Equals 方法的功能。 如果您實作等號比較運算子，則它的邏輯必須等於 Equals 的邏輯。
如果程式碼違反這項規則，則 C# 編譯器將會發出警告。
如何修正違規
若要修正此規則的違規，您應該移除等號比較運算子的實作，或是覆寫 Equals 並使這兩個方法傳回相同值。 如果等號比較運算子沒有引入不一致的行為，則您可以提供 Equals 的實作，在基底類別中呼叫 Equals 方法，以修正違規。
隱藏警告的時機
如果等號比較運算子會傳回與 Equals 之繼承實作相同的值，則您可以放心地隱藏對這項規則的警告。 範例中會包括可放心地隱藏這項規則之警告的型別。
不一致等式定義範例
.gif "ms182357.collapse_all(zh-tw,VS.110).gif")
描述
下列範例顯示等式定義不一致的型別。 BadPoint 藉由提供相等運算子的自訂實作，卻不覆寫 Equals 而使其行為相同，進而變更了相等的意義。
程式碼
using System;
namespace UsageLibrary
{
public class BadPoint
{
private int x,y, id;
private static int NextId;
static BadPoint()
{
NextId = -1;
}
public BadPoint(int x, int y)
{
this.x = x;
this.y = y;
id = ++(BadPoint.NextId);
}
public override string ToString()
{
return String.Format("([{0}] {1},{2})",id,x,y);
}
public int X {get {return x;}}
public int Y {get {return x;}}
public int Id {get {return id;}}
public override int GetHashCode()
{
return id;
}
// Violates rule: OverrideEqualsOnOverridingOperatorEquals.
// BadPoint redefines the equality operator to ignore the id value.
// This is different from how the inherited implementation of
// System.Object.Equals behaves for value types.
// It is not safe to exclude the violation for this type.
public static bool operator== (BadPoint p1, BadPoint p2)
{
return ((p1.x == p2.x) && (p1.y == p2.y));
}
// The C# compiler and rule OperatorsShouldHaveSymmetricalOverloads require this.
public static bool operator!= (BadPoint p1, BadPoint p2)
{
return !(p1 == p2);
}
}
}
範例
下列程式碼會測試 BadPoint 的行為。
using System;
namespace UsageLibrary
{
public class TestBadPoint
{
public static void Main()
{
BadPoint a = new BadPoint(1,1);
BadPoint b = new BadPoint(2,2);
BadPoint a1 = a;
BadPoint bcopy = new BadPoint(2,2);
Console.WriteLine("a = {0} and b = {1} are equal? {2}", a, b, a.Equals(b)? "Yes":"No");
Console.WriteLine("a == b ? {0}", a == b ? "Yes":"No");
Console.WriteLine("a1 and a are equal? {0}", a1.Equals(a)? "Yes":"No");
Console.WriteLine("a1 == a ? {0}", a1 == a ? "Yes":"No");
// This test demonstrates the inconsistent behavior of == and Object.Equals.
Console.WriteLine("b and bcopy are equal ? {0}", bcopy.Equals(b)? "Yes":"No");
Console.WriteLine("b == bcopy ? {0}", b == bcopy ? "Yes":"No");
}
}
}
這個範例產生下列輸出。
下列範例會顯示在技術上違反這項規則，但不會以不一致方式運作的型別。
using System;
namespace UsageLibrary
{
public struct GoodPoint
{
private int x,y;
public GoodPoint(int x, int y)
{
this.x = x;
this.y = y;
}
public override string ToString()
{
return String.Format("({0},{1})",x,y);
}
public int X {get {return x;}}
public int Y {get {return x;}}
// Violates rule: OverrideEqualsOnOverridingOperatorEquals,
// but does not change the meaning of equality;
// the violation can be excluded.
public static bool operator== (GoodPoint px, GoodPoint py)
{
return px.Equals(py);
}
// The C# compiler and rule OperatorsShouldHaveSymmetricalOverloads require this.
public static bool operator!= (GoodPoint px, GoodPoint py)
{
return !(px.Equals(py));
}
}
}
下列程式碼會測試 GoodPoint 的行為。
using System;
namespace UsageLibrary
{
public class TestGoodPoint
{
public static void Main()
{
GoodPoint a = new GoodPoint(1,1);
GoodPoint b = new GoodPoint(2,2);
GoodPoint a1 = a;
GoodPoint bcopy = new GoodPoint(2,2);
Console.WriteLine("a = {0} and b = {1} are equal? {2}", a, b, a.Equals(b)? "Yes":"No");
Console.WriteLine("a == b ? {0}", a == b ? "Yes":"No");
Console.WriteLine("a1 and a are equal? {0}", a1.Equals(a)? "Yes":"No");
Console.WriteLine("a1 == a ? {0}", a1 == a ? "Yes":"No");
// This test demonstrates the consistent behavior of == and Object.Equals.
Console.WriteLine("b and bcopy are equal ? {0}", bcopy.Equals(b)? "Yes":"No");
Console.WriteLine("b == bcopy ? {0}", b == bcopy ? "Yes":"No");
}
}
}
這個範例產生下列輸出。
下列範例藉由覆寫 Object.Equals 修正違規。
using System;
namespace Samples
{
public class Point
{
private readonly int _X;
private readonly int _Y;
public Point(int x, int y)
{
_X = x;
_Y = y;
}
public int X
{
get { return _X; }
}
public int Y
{
get { return _Y; }
}
public override int GetHashCode()
{
return _X ^ _Y;
}
public override bool Equals(object obj)
{
if (obj == null)
return false;
if (GetType() != obj.GetType())
return false;
Point point = (Point)obj;
if (_X != point.X)
return false;
return _Y == point.Y;
}
public static bool operator ==(Point point1, Point point2)
{
return Object.Equals(point1, point2);
}
public static bool operator !=(Point point1, Point point2)
{
return !Object.Equals(point1, point2);
}
}
}
下列範例藉由覆寫 ValueType.Equals 修正違規。
using System;
namespace Samples
{
public struct Point : IEquatable<Point>
{
private readonly int _X;
private readonly int _Y;
public Point(int x, int y)
{
_X = x;
_Y = y;
}
public int X
{
get { return _X; }
}
public int Y
{
get { return _Y; }
}
public override int GetHashCode()
{
return _X ^ _Y;
}
public override bool Equals(object obj)
{
if (!(obj is Point))
return false;
return Equals((Point)obj);
}
public bool Equals(Point other)
{
if (_X != other._X)
return false;
return _Y == other._Y;
}
public static bool operator ==(Point point1, Point point2)
{
return point1.Equals(point2);
}
public static bool operator !=(Point point1, Point point2)
{
return !point1.Equals(point2);
}
}
}
類別範例
描述
下列範例顯示違反此規則的類別 (參考型別)。
程式碼
using System;
namespace Samples
{
// Violates this rule
public class Point
{
private readonly int _X;
private readonly int _Y;
public Point(int x, int y)
{
_X = x;
_Y = y;
}
public int X
{
get { return _X; }
}
public int Y
{
get { return _Y; }
}
public override int GetHashCode()
{
return _X ^ _Y;
}
public static bool operator ==(Point point1, Point point2)
{
if (point1 == null || point2 == null)
return false;
if (point1.GetType() != point2.GetType())
return false;
if (point1._X != point2._X)
return false;
return point1._Y == point2._Y;
}
public static bool operator !=(Point point1, Point point2)
{
return !(point1 == point2);
}
}
}
結構範例
描述
下列範例顯示違反此規則的結構 (實值型別)。
程式碼
using System;
namespace Samples
{
// Violates this rule
public struct Point
{
private readonly int _X;
private readonly int _Y;
public Point(int x, int y)
{
_X = x;
_Y = y;
}
public int X
{
get { return _X; }
}
public int Y
{
get { return _Y; }
}
public override int GetHashCode()
{
return _X ^ _Y;
}
public static bool operator ==(Point point1, Point point2)
{
if (point1._X != point2._X)
return false;
return point1._Y == point2._Y;
}
public static bool operator !=(Point point1, Point point2)
{
return !(point1 == point2);
}
}
}