Using classic Outlook for Windows in business environments
Thank you for reaching out to the Microsoft Q&A forum and for clearly outlining your concern.
Based on the details you shared that Automatic Replies in Classic Outlook do not activate when you select File, Account, Automatic Replies. I truly understand and appreciate your effort in testing experiences and reaching out. Automatic Replies run on the server for Exchange and Microsoft 365 mailboxes and the system sends one reply per sender during your away period. In contrast, POP and IMAP accounts do not support server based Automatic Replies in Classic Outlook and therefore require a rule based workaround inside Outlook. Furthermore, organization controls such as remote domain settings, mail flow rules, or the EWS path can suppress or block replies to external senders.
To address this, please follow the steps below that suit for your situation:
1/ For Exchange or Microsoft 365 accounts, enable Automatic Replies in both Classic Outlook and on the web
- In Classic Outlook, go to File > Automatic Replies, choose Send automatic replies, optionally set a Start/End time, add your Inside My Organization and Outside My Organization messages, then OK.
- Also enable it on the server to rule out a client dialog issue: open Outlook on the web > Settings (gear) > Mail > Automatic replies, turn it On, set the time range and external reply as needed, then Save.
- Test with two senders: one inside your org and one external. By design, each sender should get a single reply during your OOF period.
- Reference: How to set up out of office automatic replies in Outlook - Microsoft Support
2/ For POP or IMAP accounts, create an automatic reply using a template and a rule in Classic Outlook
(This works while Outlook stays running on your PC.)
- Create your message template: New Email > write your away note > File > Save As > Outlook Template (*.oft).
- Create the rule: File > Manage Rules & Alerts > New Rule > Apply rule on messages I receive > Next (apply to all) > confirm Yes > select reply using a specific template > User Templates in File System > pick your .oft > Next > add exceptions if needed > Finish.
- Leave Outlook open while you’re away so replies are sent automatically.
- Reference: Use rules to create an out of office message in Outlook - Microsoft Support
3/ If replies work internally but not externally, ask your administrator to validate organization settings
- First, in Exchange Admin Center review Mail flow and Remote domains to ensure automatic replies are allowed for the relevant domains and that the AllowedOOFType permits external replies.
- Next, check mail flow rules so that automatic replies with a blank return path are not blocked and adjust the match to header or envelope where needed.
- Finally, confirm that the mailbox can set Automatic Replies through EWS and, if required, toggle the setting using the mailbox auto reply configuration at the admin level.
- Reference: Understand and troubleshoot Out of Office (OOF) replies - Exchange | Microsoft Learn
If you follow the steps above and the issue still persists, kindly attach a screenshot of the behavior to help with a quicker diagnosis. Additionally, please confirm the account type listed under File > Account Settings > Account Settings (Exchange, Microsoft 365, POP, or IMAP) so I can tailor the next steps precisely to your setup.
I hope this response has helped address your question and clarify the behavior you're experiencing. Please feel free to reply if you have any further questions, I would be happy to assist further.
Thank you for your patience and your understanding. I look forward to continuing the conversation.
If the answer is helpful, please click "Accept Answer" and kindly upvote it. If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment”.
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.