Managing personal Outlook.com account settings, security, and privacy
I’m sorry you have been dealing with this repeatedly, especially with so many purchases and years of gaming history attached to the account.
Since you can still access the account on the old Xbox, obtain the hardware ID from that console and include it in your next recovery submission. The recovery form specifically requests the hardware ID of a frequently used Xbox, and information from the old console may be more useful than details from the new one. Also provide previous passwords, billing information, and any other historical details you can remember.
Start with the Microsoft account Sign-in Helper, then retry the account recovery form. A rejected form may be submitted again up to twice per day.
Unfortunately, community moderators and support representatives cannot manually change the recovery email or phone number, send a password-reset link, or approve ownership based on purchase receipts alone. If two-step verification was enabled and none of the registered verification methods are accessible, that protection cannot be bypassed.
Thank you for your understanding.
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.