Hi @Mlekusch Jan • Thank you for reaching out.
You can add multiple Identifiers to an application only when the Sign on URL is specified. If the Sign-on URL is empty, it uses IDP-Initiated flow, which supports only one Identifier per application but when you add a URL to the Sign-on URL text box, the application uses SP-Initiated flow which supports multiple Identifiers per application. In the past, where you added multiple Identifiers, you must have a Sign-on URL specified.
So, to add multiple Identifiers you need to add a Sign-on URL, as shown below:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please "Accept the answer" if the information helped you. This will help us and others in the community as well.