Sending, receiving, and organizing email in Outlook.com
Hello, thank you for reaching out to Microsoft Q&A.
"I had removed it from sign-in preferences earlier, and since then it seems to be in a weird state." -
According to the Microsoft article below, if you remove a Microsoft domain address (alias) such as Hotmail.com, Outlook.com, MSN.com, or Live.com, you are permanently deleting that email address. It cannot be attached to any other Microsoft account again, nor can you create a new account with that address.
Going forward, you can create a new Outlook.com alias and set it as your primary address. (OR), you can continue using your existing alias (address) to sign in. Just make sure you notify your friends, neighbors, and other contacts that your email address has changed.