Apache Hadoop Distributed File System (HDFS) migration to Azure

HDInsight
Cosmos DB
Data Lake Storage
Synapse Analytics
Stream Analytics

The Hadoop Distributed File System (HDFS) is a Java-based distributed file system that provides reliable, scalable data storage that can span large clusters of commodity servers. This article provides an overview of HDFS and a guide to migrating it to Azure.

Apache®, Apache Spark®, Apache Hadoop®, Apache Hive, and the flame logo are either registered trademarks or trademarks of the Apache Software Foundation in the United States and/or other countries. No endorsement by The Apache Software Foundation is implied by the use of these marks.

HDFS Architecture and Components

HDFS has a primary/secondary design. In the following diagram, NameNode is the primary and the DataNodes are the secondaries.

Diagram that shows the HDFS components: client, NameNode, and DataNodes.

  • NameNode manages access to files and to the file system namespace, which is a hierarchy of directories.
    • Files and directories are nodes on NameNode. They have attributes such as permissions, modification and access times, and size quotas for namespace and disk space.
    • A file comprises multiple blocks. The default block size is 128 megabytes. A non-default block size can be set for a cluster by modifying the hdfs-site.xml file.
    • Each block of the file is independently replicated at multiple DataNodes. The default value for the replication factor is three, but every cluster can have its own non-default value. The replication factor can be changed at any time. A change causes a cluster re-balancing.
    • NameNode maintains the namespace tree and the mapping of file blocks to DataNodes (the physical locations of file data).
    • When an HDFS client reads a file:
      1. It contacts the NameNode for the locations of the data blocks of the file.
      2. It reads block contents from the nearest DataNode.
    • HDFS keeps the entire namespace in RAM.
  • DataNodes are the secondary nodes that perform read and write operations on the file system, and perform block operations such as creation, replication, and deletion.
    • A DataNode contains metadata files that hold the checksums of the stored files. For each block replica that's hosted by a DataNode, there's a corresponding metadata file that contains metadata about the replica, including its checksum information. The metadata file has the same base name as the block file, and extension .meta.
    • The DataNode contains the data file that holds the block’s data.
    • When a DataNode reads a file, it fetches the block locations and replica locations from the NameNode and tries to read from the nearest location.
    • An HDFS cluster can have thousands of DataNodes and tens of thousands of HDFS clients per cluster. Each DataNode can execute multiple application tasks concurrently.
    • An end-to-end checksum calculation is performed as part of the HDFS write pipeline when a block is written to DataNodes.
  • HDFS Client is the client that applications use to access files.
    • It's a code library that exports the HDFS file system interface.
    • It supports operations to read, write, and delete files, and operations to create and delete directories.
    • It performs the following steps when an application reads a file:
      • It gets from the NameNode a list of DataNodes and locations that hold the file blocks. The list includes the replicas.
      • It uses the list to get the requested blocks from the DataNodes.
    • HDFS provides an API that exposes the locations of file blocks. This allows applications like the MapReduce framework to schedule a task to run where the data is, in order to optimize read performance.

Feature map

The Azure Blob Filesystem (ABFS) driver provides an interface that makes it possible for Azure Data Lake Storage to act as an HDFS file system. The following table compares the core functionality of the ABFS driver and Data Lake Storage to that of HDFS.

Feature The ABFS driver and Data Lake Storage HDFS
Access that's compatible with Hadoop You can manage and access data just as you would with HDFS. The ABFS driver is available in all Apache Hadoop environments, including Azure HDInsight and Azure Databricks. A MapR cluster can access an external HDFS cluster with the hdfs:// or webhdfs:// protocols
POSIX permissions The security model for Data Lake Gen2 supports access control list (ACL) and POSIX permissions along with some extra granularity that's specific to Data Lake Storage Gen2. Settings can be configured by using admin tools or frameworks like Apache Hive and Apache Spark. Jobs that require file system features like strictly atomic directory renames, fine-grained HDFS permissions, or HDFS symlinks can only work on HDFS.
Cost effectiveness Data Lake Storage offers low-cost storage capacity and transactions. Azure Blob Storage lifecycles help to lower costs by adjusting billing rates as data moves through its lifecycle.
Optimized driver The ABFS driver is optimized for big data analytics. The corresponding REST APIs are provided through the distributed file system (DFS) endpoint, dfs.core.windows.net.
Block Size Blocks is equivalent to a single Append API invocation (the Append API creates a new block) and is limited to 100 MB per invocation. However, the write pattern supports calling Append many times per file (even in parallel) to a maximum of 50,000 and then calling Flush (equivalent to PutBlockList). This is the way the maximum files size of 4.75TB is achieved. HDFS stores the data in a data block. You set the block size by setting a value in the hdfs-site.xml file in the Hadoop directory. The default size is 128 MB.
Default ACLS Files don't have default ACLs and aren't enabled by default. Files don't have default ACLs.
Binary Files Binary files can be moved to Azure Blob Storage in a non-hierarchical namespace. Objects in Blob Storage are accessible via the Azure Storage REST API, Azure PowerShell, Azure CLI, or an Azure Storage client library. Client libraries are available for different languages, including .NET, Java, Node.js, Python, Go, PHP, and Ruby Hadoop provides the ability to read and write binary files. SequenceFile is a flat file that consists of a binary key and value pairs. The SequenceFile provides Writer, Reader, and Sorter classes for writing, reading, and sorting. Convert the image or video file into a SequenceFile and store it in HDFS. Then use the HDFS SequenceFileReader/Writer methods or the put command: bin/hadoop fs -put /src_image_file /dst_image_file
Permission inheritance Data Lake Storage uses the POSIX-style model and behaves the same as Hadoop if ACLs control access to an object. For more information, see Access control lists (ACLs) in Data Lake Storage Gen2. Permissions for an item are stored on the item itself, not inherited after the item exists. Permissions are only inherited if default permissions are set on the parent item before the child item is created.
Data replication Data in an Azure Storage account is replicated three times in the primary region. Zone-redundant storage is the recommended replication option. It synchronously replicates across three Azure availability zones in the primary region. By default a file’s replication factor is three. For critical files or files that are accessed often, a higher replication factor improves fault tolerance and increases read bandwidth.
Sticky bit In the context of Data Lake Storage, it's unlikely that the sticky bit is required. Briefly, if the sticky bit is enabled on a directory, a child item can only be deleted or renamed by the user that owns the child item. The sticky bit isn't shown in the Azure portal. The sticky bit can be set on directories to prevent anyone except the superuser, directory owner, or file owner from deleting or moving files within the directory. Setting the sticky bit for a file has no effect.

Common challenges of an on-premises HDFS

Diagram that shows the common challenges when implementing HDFS.

The many challenges presented by an on-premises HDFS implementation can be reasons to consider the advantages of migrating to the cloud:

  • Frequent HDFS version upgrades
  • Increasing amounts of data
  • Having many small files that increase the pressure on the NameNode, which controls the metadata of all the files in the cluster. More files often means more read traffic on the NameNode when clients read the files, and more calls when clients are writing.
  • If multiple teams in the organization require different datasets, splitting the HDFS clusters by use case or organization isn't possible. The result is that data duplication increases, which increases costs and reduces efficiency.
  • The NameNode can become a performance bottleneck as the HDFS cluster is scaled up or out.
  • Prior to Hadoop 2.0, all client requests to an HDFS cluster first pass through the NameNode, because all the metadata is stored in a single NameNode. This design makes the NameNode a possible bottleneck and single point of failure. If the NameNode fails, the cluster is unavailable.

Migration considerations

Here are some things that are important to consider when you plan a migration of HDFS to Data Lake Storage:

  • Consider aggregating data that's in small files into a single file on Data Lake Storage.
  • List all the directory structures in HDFS and replicate similar zoning in Data Lake Storage. You can obtain the directory structure of HDFS by using the hdfs -ls command.
  • List all the roles that are defined in the HDFS cluster so that you can replicate them in the target environment.
  • Note the data lifecycle policy of the files that are stored in HDFS.
  • Keep in mind that some system features of HDFS aren't available on Data Lake Storage, including:
    • Strictly atomic renaming of directories
    • Fine-grained HDFS permissions
    • HDFS symlinks
  • Azure Storage has geo-redundant replication, but it's not always wise to use it. It does provide data redundancy and geographic recovery, but a failover to a more distant location can severely degrade performance and incur additional costs. Consider whether the higher availability of the data is worth it.
  • If files have names with the same prefixes, HDFS treats them as a single partition. Therefore, if you use Azure Data Factory, all data movement units (DMUs) write to a single partition.

Diagram of the process flow for partitions and job parallelism.

  • If you use Data factory for data transfer, scan through each directory, excluding snapshots, and check the directory size by using the hdfs du command. If there are multiple subdirectories and large amounts of data, initiate multiple copy activities in Data Factory. For example, use one copy per subdirectory rather than transferring the entire directory by using a single copy activity.

Diagram of the process flow for number of copy activities.

  • Data platforms are often used for longer term retention of information that may have been removed from systems of record. You should plan to create tape backups or snapshots of the archived data. Consider replicating the information to a recovery site. Usually data is archived either for compliance or for historical data purposes. Before you archive data you should have a clear reason for keeping it. Also, decide when archived data is to be removed and establish processes to remove it at that time.
  • The low cost of the Archive access tier of Data Lake Storage makes it an attractive option for archiving data. For more information, see Archive access tier.
  • When an HDFS client uses the ABFS driver to access Blob Storage, there can be instances where the method that's used by the client isn't supported and AzureNativeFileSystem throws an UnsupportedOperationException. For example, append(Path f, int bufferSize, Progressable progress) isn't currently supported. To check on issues related to the ABFS driver, see Hadoop features and fixes.
  • There's a backported version of the ABFS driver for use on older Hadoop clusters. For more information, see Backport for ABFS Driver.
  • In an Azure virtual networking environment, the DistCp tool doesn't support Azure ExpressRoute private peering with an Azure Storage virtual network endpoint. For more information, see Use Azure Data Factory to migrate data from an on-premises Hadoop cluster to Azure Storage.

Migration approach

The typical approach to migrating HDFS to Data Lake Storage uses these steps:

Diagram that shows the six steps for an HDFS to Data Lake Storage migration.

HDFS assessment

On-premises assessment scripts provide information that helps you to determine which workloads can be migrated to Azure and whether the data should be migrated all at once or a piece at a time. Third-party tools like Unravel can provide metrics and support auto-assessment of the on-premises HDFS. Some important factors to consider when planning include:

  • Data volume
  • Business impact
  • Ownership of data
  • Processing complexity
  • Extract, transfer, and load (ETL) complexity
  • Personally identifiable information (PII) and other sensitive data

Based on such factors, you can formulate a plan to move data to Azure that minimizes downtime and business disruption. Perhaps sensitive data can remain on-premises. Historical data can be moved and tested prior to moving an incremental load.

The following decision flow helps decide the criteria and commands to run to get the right information.

Diagram that shows a decision flowchart for data migration strategy and planning.

HDFS commands for getting assessment metrics from HDFS include:

  • List all the directories in a location:

    hdfs dfs -ls books

  • Recursively list all files in a location:

    hdfs dfs -ls -R books

  • Get the size of the HDFS directory and files:

    hadoop fs -du -s -h command

    The hadoop fs -du -s -h command displays the size of the HDFS files and directory. Since the Hadoop file system replicates every file, the actual physical size of the file is the number of file replicas multiplied by the size of one replica.

  • Determine whether ACLs are enabled. To do this, obtain the value of dfs.namenode.acls.enabled in Hdfs-site.xml. Knowing the value helps in planning access control on the Azure Storage account. For information about the contents of this file, see Default file settings.

Partner tools such as Unravel provide assessment reports for planning data migration. The tools must run in the on-premises environment or connect to the Hadoop cluster to generate reports.

  • The following Unravel report provides statistics, per directory, about the small files in the directory:

    Screenshot of a small files report.

  • The following report provides statistics, per directory, about the files in the directory:

    Screenshot of an all files report.

Transfer data

Data must be transferred to Azure as outlined in your migration plan. Transferring requires the following activities:

  1. Identify all of the ingestion points.

    If, because of security requirements, data can't be landed to the cloud directly, then on-premises can serve as an intermediate landing zone. You can build pipelines in Data Factory to pull the data from on-premises systems, or use AZCopy scripts to push the data to the Azure Storage account.

    Common ingestion sources include:

    1. SFTP server
    2. File ingestion
    3. Database ingestion
    4. Database dump
    5. Change data capture
    6. Streaming ingestion
  2. Plan the number of storage accounts required.

    To plan the number of storage accounts required, understand the total load on the current HDFS. You can use the TotalLoad metric, which is the current number of concurrent file accesses across all DataNodes. Set the limit on the storage account in the region according to the TotalLoad value on-premises and the expected growth on Azure. If it's possible to increase the limit, a single storage account may suffice. However for a data lake, it's best to keep a separate storage account for each zone, to prepare for future data volume growth. Other reasons to keep a separate storage account include:

    • Access control
    • Resiliency requirements
    • Data replication requirements
    • Exposing the data for public usage

    When you enable a hierarchical namespace on a storage account, you can't change it back to a flat namespace. Workloads such as backups and VM image files don't gain any benefit from a hierarchical namespace.

    Diagram that shows a decision flowchart to determine number of storage accounts.

    For information about securing the traffic between your virtual network and the storage account over a private link, see Securing Storage Accounts.

    For information about default limits for Azure Storage accounts, see Scalability and performance targets for standard storage accounts. The ingress limit applies to the data that's sent to a storage account. The egress limit applies to the data that's received from a storage account

  3. Decide on availability requirements.

    You can specify the replication factor for Hadoop platforms in hdfs-site.xml or specify it per file. You can configure replication on Data Lake Storage according to the nature of the data. If an application requires that the data be reconstructed in case of a loss, then zone-redundant storage (ZRS) is an option. In Data Lake Storage ZRS, data is copied synchronously across three availability zones in the primary region. For applications that require high availability and that can run in more than one region, copy the data to a secondary region. This is geo-redundant replication.

    Diagram that shows a decision chart for replication requirements.

  4. Check for corrupted or missing blocks.

    Check the block scanner report for corrupted or missing blocks. If there are any, wait for the file to be restored before transferring it.

    Diagram that shows a decision chart for handling corrupted or missing blocks.

  5. Check if NFS is enabled.

    Check if NFS is enabled on the on-premises Hadoop platform by checking the core-site.xml file. It has the nfsserver.groups and nfsserver.hosts properties.

    The NFS 3.0 feature is in preview in Data Lake Storage. A few features may not be supported yet. For more information, see Network File System (NFS) 3.0 protocol support for Azure Blob Storage.

    Diagram that shows a decision flowchart for enabling NFS.

  6. Check Hadoop file formats.

    Use the following decision flow chart for guidance on how to handle file formats. Diagram that shows a decision flowchart for handling the various file types.

  7. Choose an Azure solution for data transfer.

    Data transfer can be online over the network or offline by using physical devices. Which method to use depends on data volume, network bandwidth, and frequency of the data transfer. Historical data has to be transferred only once. Incremental loads require repeated ongoing transfers.

    Data transfer methods are discussed in the list that follows. For more information about choosing types of data transfer, see Choose an Azure solution for data transfer.

    1. Azcopy

      Azcopy is a command-line utility that can copy files from HDFS to a storage account. This is an option for high-bandwidth transfers (over 1 GBPS).

      Here's a sample command to move an HDFS directory:

      *azcopy copy "C:\local\path" "https://account.blob.core.windows.net/mycontainer1/?sv=2018-03-28&ss=bjqt&srt=sco&sp=rwddgcup&se=2019-05-01T05:01:17Z&st=2019-04-30T21:01:17Z&spr=https&sig=MGCXiyEzbtttkr3ewJIh2AR8KrghSy1DGM9ovN734bQF4%3D" --recursive=true*
      
    2. DistCp

      DistCp is a command-line utility in Hadoop that can do distributed copy operations in a Hadoop cluster. DistCp creates several map tasks in the Hadoop cluster to copy data from the source to the sink. This push approach is good when there's adequate network bandwidth, and it doesn’t require extra compute resources to be provisioned for data migration. However, if the source HDFS cluster is already running out of capacity and additional compute can't be added, then consider using Data Factory with the DistCp copy activity to pull rather than push the files.

      *hadoop distcp -D fs.azure.account.key.<account name>.blob.core.windows.net=<Key> wasb://<container>@<account>.blob.core.windows.net<path to wasb file> hdfs://<hdfs path>*
      
    3. Azure Data Box for large data transfers

      Azure Data Box is a physical device that's ordered from Microsoft. It provides large-scale data transfers, and it's an offline data transfer option when network bandwidth is limited and data volume is high (for example, when volume is between a few terabytes and a petabyte).

      You connect a Data Box to the LAN to transfer data to it. You then ship it back to the Microsoft data center, where the data is transferred by Microsoft engineers to the configured storage account.

      There are multiple Data Box options that differ by the data volumes that they can handle. For more information about the Data Box approach, see Azure Data Box documentation - Offline transfer.

    4. Data Factory

      Data Factory is a data-integration service that helps create data-driven workflows that orchestrate and automate data movement and data transformation. You can use it when there's sufficient network bandwidth available and there's a requirement to orchestrate and monitor data migration. You can use Data Factory for regular incremental loadings of data when the incremental data arrives on the on-premises system as a first hop and can't be directly transferred to the Azure storage account because of security restrictions.

      For more |information about the various transfer approaches, see Data transfer for large datasets with moderate to high network bandwidth.

      For information about using Data Factory to copy data from HDFS, see Copy data from the HDFS server using Azure Data Factory or Synapse Analytics

    5. Partner solutions such as WANdisco LiveData migration

      The WANdisco LiveData Platform for Azure is one of Microsoft’s preferred solutions for migrations from Hadoop to Azure. You access its capabilities by using the Azure portal and the Azure CLI. For more information, see Migrate your Hadoop data lakes with WANdisco LiveData Platform for Azure.

Contributors

This article is maintained by Microsoft. It was originally written by the following contributors.

Principal authors:

Other contributors:

To see non-public LinkedIn profiles, sign in to LinkedIn.

Next steps

Azure product introductions

Azure product reference

Other